Apple has accused Spotify of “deceptive rhetoric” in its response to allegations that its tight management of the App Retailer arms its personal music service an unfair benefit.
“After utilizing the App Retailer for years to dramatically develop their enterprise, Spotify seeks to maintain all the advantages of the App Retailer ecosystem — together with the substantial income that they draw from the App Retailer’s prospects — with out making any contributions to that market,” Apple mentioned in a press release late on Thursday in California.
“Spotify is free to construct apps for — and compete on — our merchandise and platforms, and we hope they do.”
The iPhone maker additionally accused Spotify of “attempting to squeeze” artists, musicians and songwriters, in the identical means that it was attempting to “make more cash off others’ work” within the App Retailer, pointing to Spotify’s attraction towards a proposed enhance to its US royalty funds.
Spotify this week filed a European antitrust complaint towards Apple, alleging that it had behaved unlawfully and abused its App Retailer dominance to favour Apple Music.
Apple’s streaming service has rapidly grow to be Spotify’s greatest international rival because it launched in 2015, attracting greater than 50m paying subscribers by the beginning of this 12 months.
Spotify, which stays the worldwide chief with 87m paying prospects, alleged that Apple held again higher development due to its preliminary 30 per cent charge on all funds for digital items within the App Retailer. Apple additionally restricted the way it communicates with its prospects and restricted its integration with Apple’s HomePod speaker or Siri digital assistant, Spotify mentioned.
The timing of Spotify’s assault was robust for Apple, coming in the identical week that it introduced an occasion to advertise new digital media providers, in addition to setting the date for its annual convention for app builders in early June.
“Spotify wouldn’t be the enterprise they’re immediately with out the App Retailer ecosystem, however now they’re leveraging their scale to keep away from contributing to sustaining that ecosystem for the subsequent era of app entrepreneurs,” Apple mentioned on Thursday.
A Spotify spokesman on Friday mentioned in response: “Each monopolist will counsel they’ve achieved nothing incorrect and can argue that they’ve the very best pursuits of rivals and customers at coronary heart.”
The row has erupted at a second when US tech corporations have discovered themselves in politicians’ crosshairs from Washington DC to Brussels, with US presidential hopeful Elizabeth Warren final week criticising Apple for selling its personal apps contained in the App Retailer.
“Both they run the platform or they play within the retailer,” Ms Warren advised tech information website The Verge. “They don’t get to do each on the identical time.”
Daniel Ek, Spotify’s chief government, told the FT in an interview on Thursday that he would have “no alternative” however to boost costs if Apple continues to cost its charge for promoting via the App Retailer — even when that meant leaving Apple Music because the cheaper different.
Apple countered that Spotify “omitted” the truth that its charge falls to 15 per cent as soon as a buyer has been paying for greater than a 12 months. Whereas Spotify requested to be handled in the identical means as Uber or Deliveroo, Apple identified that solely digital items and providers that depend on its in-app buy system should pay the charge below its App Retailer guidelines.
“Apple connects Spotify to our customers,” Apple mentioned, by offering instruments for creating, distributing and charging for its service, which it described as “no small endeavor”. “Spotify is asking to maintain all these advantages whereas additionally retaining 100 per cent of the income.”
However Spotify disputed Apple’s account.
“We filed our grievance as a result of Apple’s actions harm competitors and customers, and are in clear violation of the regulation,” a spokesperson mentioned on Friday. “That is evident in Apple’s perception that Spotify’s customers on iOS are Apple prospects and never Spotify prospects, which fits to the very coronary heart of the difficulty with Apple.”